ϼ

NEWS

Albuquerque’s two James Beard finalists come up short in Chicago

Bow & Arrow Brewing Co. and Mesa Provisions were this year’s award hopefuls

Published Modified

Resounding cheers erupted at Bow & Arrow Brewing Co. on Monday evening as a presenter at the James Beard Awards said the New Mexico brewery’s name before sharing the winner of this year’s Outstanding Bar category.

But an equally loud symphony of sighs filled the air as the presenter revealed the category’s winner: Portland, Oregon’s Scotch Lounge. Still, bargoers raised their drinks in tribute to the brewery sharing the national spotlight with four other bars across the nation.

“It’s a massive achievement,” said Andrew Krosche, Bow & Arrow’s head brewer. “We do not have food, we do not have a full bar. … Other finalists had a lot more diversity of what they could offer, so I’m very proud to make it there.”

Bow & Arrow was one of two finalists representing Albuquerque and the state at this year’s James Beard Awards in Chicago — a recognition considered to be one of the most prestigious honors in the culinary world.

The other finalist was Mesa Provisions chef Steve Riley, who competed against four others across Nevada, Arizona and Oklahoma in the Best Chef: Southwest category. Riley also did not win, ultimately losing out to Las Vegas, Nevada’s Sarah Thompson of the restaurant Casa Playa.

Riley and Bow & Arrow first kicked off their 2026 James Beard journeys in January as two of six semifinalists from New Mexico. Then, in March, the pair were named finalists.

Riley is no stranger to the James Beard Awards — he was also a finalist in 2024. In the days leading up to Monday, Riley said the nerves were minimal considering he knew what to expect this time around. Riley said he was more concerned with making sure his restaurant staff was all set to operate a weekend without him and his two sous chefs, Jordan Valdez and Hanna Chaney.

“In 2024, when I got back from Chicago, I told them both, ‘If this happens again, I’m taking you both,’” Riley said, adding that Valdez and Chaney do “all the hard work” at Mesa Provisions.

The inclusion meant a lot to both Chaney and Valdez, who’ve been working with Riley for roughly five and six years, respectively.

“It’s nice to get that kind of respect and love and approval,” Valdez said. “We work so hard for him because he gives it back to us.”

Chaney agreed, saying it felt “huge” to see Riley’s and the Mesa Provisions team’s hard work pay off, bringing Albuquerque national attention.

Also joining Riley in Chicago was his partner, Nikki Zabicki, who Riley said has been his “rock” throughout his culinary journey with Mesa Provisions, which she has helped mold.

While accolades were never the goal for Riley when he became a chef, he said it “definitely feels good” to have made it to Chicago a second time.

Riley remembers the day he told his friend he was “going to open the best restaurant in Albuquerque.” He was sleeping on his friend’s couch at the time, back home from a stint living and working in Los Angeles.

“It wasn’t easy, and it did require a little bit of luck, but it also required a lot of determination, a lot of willpower and a lot of (telling myself,) ‘It doesn’t matter how I get this done, I’m going to get it done,’” Riley said.

For Bow & Arrow, a repeat semifinalist from 2024, all of the James Beard love came during a milestone year. The brewery is celebrating a decade of making beer inspired by locally sourced, Indigenous ingredients — a specialization CEO Shyla Sheppard said has set Bow & Arrow apart in a challenging craft beer industry that has faced headwinds in recent years.

“Staying focused on our core values and our purpose, that’s kept us motivated,” Sheppard said. “We’re just trying to continue to stay hungry, stay curious and be innovative.”

Sheppard said the James Beard recognition gave her and her team a moment to reflect on making it through the past decade and the inclusive space they’ve built at Bow & Arrow.

“A lot of people believe in us, which is amazing,” Sheppard said.

Sheppard approached Monday with a busy to-do list and plenty of excitement from friends, family and employees. She was also assembling an awards-night outfit that came from her grandmother and reflected the craftsmanship of New Mexico.

While Bow & Arrow didn’t take home an award, Sheppard said the experience allowed the brewery to bring a taste of New Mexico and its Indigenous communities to Chicago. She said Bow & Arrow making it as far as it did “just demonstrates that there’s a place for us at the highest levels of hospitality and food and beverage.”

The finalists didn’t leave Chicago empty-handed.

Sheppard said she and her wife, Bow & Arrow co-founder Missy Begay, also checked in with businesses the brewery recently started distributing its beers to in the Windy City.

The trip also provided networking opportunities with chefs and culinary talent across the country for Riley, which he said he made a point of this go around despite his more introverted nature. The networking aspect was also a point of excitement for his sous chefs.

“Win or not, we’re sitting there next to people at the top of their fields, and that’s — more than anything — what matters,” Chaney said.

Sheppard agreed.

“We’re just happy to be in the same room and happy to be one of five in the ϼ States in the Outstanding Bars category,” Sheppard said. “We feel like we’ve already won. We’re just really proud of our team and what we do.”

Riley said he still hopes to one day see an Albuquerque chef win in the Best Chef: Southwest category, whether it be him or someone else. But winning awards isn’t everything.

“We win every day that we open this restaurant and people come in and they have smiles on their faces,” Riley said. “That whole interaction, that is why we do it. That’s why we’re here every day.”

Kylie Garcia covers retail and real estate for the Journal. You can reach her at kgarcia@abqjournal.com.