LOCAL COLUMN
OPINION: What Alice's escape reveals about zoo captivity
On March 29, Alice, a wild-born Asian elephant, escaped her enclosure at the ABQ BioPark Zoo where she’s been held captive since 1991. Only Alice will ever know why she broke through welded steel and stepped, briefly, into freedom. What we do know is that, like humans, elephants possess the ability to plan, communicate those plans and adjust them based on risk. This parallels what we understand about elephant neuroanatomy:
Elephants share key features with human brains, including a substantial cerebellum. The cerebellum plays a key role in empathy, planning and anticipatory actions. Further similarities occur in regions associated with self-awareness. Science tells us Alice understood she was leaving her enclosure.
Science also tells us her barren, artificial environment harms her by preventing behavior inherent to elephants. Elephants have evolved to move. Wild elephants travel a dozen or more miles each day, and at times more than 60 miles in a 24-hour period. One study of elephants in the Namib Desert found a group travelled over 370 miles in five months. Elephants have evolved longer legs precisely because moving across vast, varied terrain is central to their survival.
The BioPark asserts its elephant enclosure covers 5 acres. In reality, the elephants don’t have access to the full enclosure and are restricted to less than 3 acres during the day, before being confined at night to a barn. Even taking the BioPark at its word, Alice would need to walk roughly 38 laps of that 5-acre enclosure just to match the average daily distance of her wild counterparts. However, distance alone misses the point. Each of those laps would unfold in a static, unchanging environment, devoid of the varied terrain, plant life, foraging opportunities and social interactions that define a wild elephant’s life. To approximate a baseline of natural movement, Alice would need to repeat the same loop every day of every year, without variation.
Even this bleak understanding overlooks another cost: the absence of natural substrates, and the well-documented impact that hard, artificial surfaces have on elephant feet. Approximately 60 million years of evolution has shaped elephants into long-distance beings with refined anatomy and physiology for a life in motion. Long distance walking is essential to elephants’ well-being and to the health of their feet. Many zoo enclosures are lined with concrete, which exerts more pressure on elephants’ feet than the natural substrates they evolved to walk on, causing chronic foot and musculoskeletal issues. Studies have documented foot disease in 50-80% of zoo elephants examined, and post-mortem exams on 21 deceased zoo elephants discovered foot pathologies in every individual, suggesting that most zoo elephants will develop foot issues by their death.
Elephants without space to roam develop stereotypical behaviors, like uninhibited rocking, bobbing and swaying, which are physical manifestations of brain damage. Studies have shown that 85% of zoo elephants have displayed compulsive behavior or stereotypies. Stereotypical behaviors have never been observed in wild elephants.
The BioPark has suggested that the solution to Alice’s escape is to “reinforce the enclosure.” But when a cognitively complex nonhuman animal breaks through steel to leave her enclosure, the question is not simply how she got out, but why elephants can be kept in zoos at all. Alice’s escape reveals not just suffering, but a deeper injustice: the lack of a fundamental right to liberty. Courts can provide a remedy.
Alice does not need a reinforced enclosure. She needs what science, common sense and justice demand: space and the opportunity to live autonomously in an environment that meets her unique and extraordinary needs. Accredited sanctuaries and rewilding facilities offer that possibility. Zoos do not.
Jake Davis is a senior staff attorney with the Nonhuman Rights Project. He has argued multiple, complex civil rights cases on behalf of nonhuman animals in various jurisdictions.